Jim Jubak

To print article, click Print on your browser's File menu.

Go back


Posted 12/20/2005

Jubak's Picks
Check out Jim's top stocks for the next 12 months


50 Best Stocks Today

See Jim's list of the 50 best stocks in the world for the long term.


Future Fantastic 50 Stocks

See Jim's reader-assisted Future Fantastic 50 portfolio.


Dividend stocks for income investors

See Jim's new portfolio to help navigate the treacherous interest-rate environment.



Cool Tools
Get market news by e-mail
See if refinancing works
Personal finance bookshelf
Letters from MSN Money readers
Find It!
Article Index
Fast Answers
Tools Index
Site map
MSN Money









Jubak's Journal

Recent articles:
• Global growth means a risky 2006, 12/16/2005
• 5 stocks fired up by energy mergers, 12/14/2005
• 5 big 'ifs' investors face in 2006, 12/13/2005
More...



 Jubak's Journal
Stocks for the 2006 commodities crunch

Rising prices for basic materials could feed an inflation surge, hitting the market and your pocketbook. Protect yourself by investing in the right commodities stocks.

By Jim Jubak

Inflation -- as measured by the Consumer Price Index, anyway -- showed a huge drop in November. Driven by a 16% plunge in energy prices, this broad measure of inflation at the consumer level fell by 0.6% from October. That's the biggest monthly decline in inflation since 1949, and it reset the annual inflation rate to 3.5% from a 4.3% reading in October.

But before you break out the champagne, I suggest you take a look at the evidence that the global system for producing and delivering commodities is breaking down under the pressure of demand. The world may indeed have plenty of oil, coal, copper, iron, nickel and other essential industrial commodities in the ground to meet current demand -- especially with the big incentives to production that current high prices provide. But there's increasing evidence that commodity industries are suffering from shortages in key materials, gear and personnel. And because of those shortages, they can't get the oil, coal, etc., out of the ground without substantially higher production costs.

And that argues that we're in for another round of commodity inflation in 2006 that will increasingly feed inflation for the economy in general. In November, the core CPI -- that's the CPI with the effects of food and energy prices stripped out -- climbed by 0.2%. That doesn't seem like much, but November marked the second consecutive month where the core rate climbed by 0.2% instead of the 0.1% monthly increases of April through September. In January 2004, the core CPI hit a 40-year low at an annual rate of 1.1%. With the November number, the core CPI is showing annual inflation of 2.1%. That's still low, but you don't have to be chairman of the Federal Reserve to know which way the trend is headed.
See the news
that affects your stocks.

Check out our
new News center.



If core inflation gets worrisome enough, the stock and bond markets can forget about the Federal Reserve moving to the sidelines after one or two more interest-rate hikes in 2006. That wouldn't be so important except that the bullish case for stocks in 2006 hinges on an early end to the Fed's interest rate increases. If commodity inflation in 2006 leaks through into higher core CPI inflation, you can forget about that scenario for the Fed -- and forget about a good year in 2006 for stocks and bonds.


Related news and commentary on MSN Money
Related resources image
Global growth means a risky 2006
5 stocks fired up by energy mergers
5 ways to tap into onshore drilling boom
5 energy stocks for the cold of winter
How the Fed lost the inflation fight


Burning through rubber
So what's all this hullabaloo about a shortage of tires?

On Dec. 14, Canadian Pacific Railway (CP, news, msgs) said a major customer, Fording Canadian Coal Trust (FDG, news, msgs), had forecast a drop in production due to a global shortage of tires for the heavy equipment that hauls coal. Fording lowered its projections for 2005 sales by about 4%, and for 2006 by 9% to 13%, from earlier Wall Street estimates.

The problem isn't limited to Fording, nor is it especially short term. Coal-mining companies operating on the other side of the U.S.-Canadian border in the Powder River Basin of northeast Wyoming, such as Arch Coal (ACI, news, msgs) and Peabody Energy (BTU, news, msgs), have reported similar tire shortages and warned of potential production problems.

With big manufacturers of these specialized tires, such as Goodyear Tire & Rubber (GT, news, msgs) and Bridgestone (BRDCY, news, msgs), just now looking to expand their plants, the shortage could go on for a while -- through 2007, Goodyear has estimated.

Why the shortage? The U.S. military operations in Afghanistan and Iraq have added to demand, but the big culprit is the energy industry itself. Coal and copper mines, for example, are running at full speed. That increases the demand for tires as new equipment is added and as existing equipment is run for more hours.

One huge drain on the tire supply has been the rapid expansion of oil-sand operations. Turning oil sands into oil has become economically attractive with oil at $60 a barrel, but producing oil from oil sands is essentially a mining-and-cooking operation with large numbers of huge heavy-duty trucks required to move the sands from where they're mined to the plants that cook them into oil.

If it was just a question of tires, even of tires across a huge swath of the U.S.-Canada coal and oil-sands belt, I don't think this would be a big enough problem to bump up the core inflation rate in 2006. But it's not limited to this one problem.

Economics 101
A world away, a shortage of construction workers and engineers has led to rising costs and postponed projects in the booming commodities economies of Australia and New Zealand. Origin Energy (OGFGF, news, msgs) has delayed a proposed gas facility in New Zealand because problems in finding skilled workers have doubled the estimated cost of the project. In the Australian aluminum sector, Alcoa (AA, news, msgs), its Australian partner Alumina (AWC, news, msgs) and Rio Tinto (RTP, news, msgs) have put plant expansions on hold until construction costs come down.

Shortages of rigs, equipment and engineers are roiling the global oil industry. Royal Dutch Shell (RDS.A, news, msgs) recently announced that it would hike capital spending by nearly 27%, to $19 billion in 2006. The company certainly needs to increase capital spending to make up for the reserves that vanished off its books when the company corrected earlier faulty accounting, but CFO Peter Voser told Wall Street analysts that about 25% of the increase is a result of price increases in the cost of drilling rigs and other equipment because of shortages in those markets.

I know Royal Dutch Shell is drilling in some of the most difficult environments in the world, but the degree of price inflation is still stunning. On the Russian island of Sakhalin, where Shell has a 55% interest in a massive oil and gas project, the company has said that costs will climb to $20 billion, double earlier estimates.

All the delays in adding new supply (and the bottlenecks that instead are reducing supply in some instances) make meeting the very modest forecasts for growth in global commodities demand much more of a challenge than it seems. The Organization of Petroleum Exporting Countries forecasts 1.9% growth in global oil demand in 2006, and the International Energy Agency estimate of 2.2% growth isn't all that different.

Strains that are showing in the global commodities supply system say that meeting even that modest growth in demand with a matching increase in supply isn't by any means a sure thing next year. And that much of this new supply will come on line with substantially higher production costs.

This isn't rocket science but basic classical economics: When a system operates at the edge of full capacity, prices rise as unexpected glitches slow production here and there or require extraordinary efforts and extra costs to keep the system running. I think that's what we can expect in most global commodities markets in 2006.
Little in the bargain bin
How do you invest to take advantage of this kind of commodity inflation?

First, you buy the shares of the companies that are the beneficiaries of the shortages and the price increases. In a situation like this, the dollars flow to the companies that own the drilling rigs, that sell the pipes and connectors, that supply the mining equipment and that build the infrastructure.

I loaded up Jubak's Picks with companies like this in 2005, and I still own many of them. I expect that stocks currently in the portfolio, such as Nabors Industries (NBR, news, msgs), Chicago Bridge & Iron (CBI, news, msgs), Ensco International (ESV, news, msgs), General Cable (BGC, news, msgs) and Noble (NE, news, msgs) will do well in 2006 as well. And with this column, I'll be adding Grant Prideco (GRP, news, msgs) to this list. The company is a late-cycle play on increased oil and gas exploration and production.

Second, you should buy the shares of selected commodities producers when a company shows signs of being able to increase production at a time when the rest of its sector can't add capacity.
Jim Jubak's newsletter
Get the latest from Jim Jubak. Sign up to receive his free weekly newsletter.

Your e-mail address:
 

Learn more about newsletters
 


The problem is that very little on the producer side is a bargain. While investors got a decent opportunity to buy into the oil and gas sector when the whole group sold off in early October, I can't tell you when the next opportunity like that might arise. The sector that interests me most as an investor is the U.S.-Canadian natural gas industry. Because it's tough to move natural gas to the United States (where it's in short supply) from overseas fields (where it is comparatively plentiful) due to a lack of liquefied natural gas terminals, U.S. prices will rise in 2006. But even here, I'll wait until warmer weather or some other short-term trend drives down prices in this volatile sector.

While you're waiting, I think it's still possible to find individual stocks that are relative bargains. One that comes to mind is Anglo American (AAUK, news, msgs), which is in the process of selling off its gold, paper and steel businesses in order to focus on its core business of mining diamonds, platinum, coal, iron and base metals. Even here, though, I'm going to wait until the end-of-the-year dust clears: It looks to me like we'll end the year with profit-taking, as momentum players who drove up stocks in November and early December sell to lock in their end-of-the-quarter numbers. Let's see if January brings a better entry point. 



Updates

Sell EMC Corp (EMC, news, msgs)
The numbers haven't looked good for EMC recently, and I'm selling the stock out of Jubak's Picks with this column. Dell's (DELL, news, msgs) last quarterly report in early number suggested that EMC was losing market share in the enterprise storage market and, at best, showing slower growth in the market than its partner Dell. The stock first stalled just south of $14 and then, more recently, retreated below the key 50-day moving average. This should be a seasonally strong period for EMC, but the stock certainly isn't showing any strength here. I'm going to look for more potential somewhere else. I have a 6% gain on the stock since I added it to Jubak's Picks on Oct. 29, 2004. (Full disclosure: I will sell my personal position in EMC three days after this column is posted.)

Buy Grant Prideco (GRP, news, msgs)
Somebody has got to make the things that go into drilling rigs, and in the markets for premium steel tubing and drilling products that somebody is often Grant Prideco. (The company controls nearly 50% of the drilling products market.) The company's order backlog climbed to $742 million at the end of the third quarter -- not bad for a company that did $946 million in sales for all of 2004. As a manufacturer with a high percentage of fixed costs, Grant Prideco should see earnings soar as volumes increase. Wall Street analysts project 209% earnings growth in 2005 and 48% in 2006 -- which is why the stock looks a little pricey on trailing 12-month earnings per share. Do the valuation on forward earnings, though, and the shares sell for a more modest 17.4 times projected 2006 earnings per share. As of Dec. 21, I'm adding Grant Prideco to Jubak's Picks with a target price of $52 a share by September 2006.

New developments on past columns
Why the greenback is back: Investors are getting more enthusiastic about the restructuring story at Siemens AG (SI, news, msgs) every time the company actually executes a bit of its strategy. On Dec. 15, the company announced that it had reached a deal to sell a flexible circuit manufacturing line to 3M (MMM, news, msgs). On the same day, it requested permission to acquire another 21% stake in Power Machines, a Russian company that makes turbines for power plants. Both moves continue Siemens' drive to refocus the company on its most profitable businesses. With Siemens, investors get three trends for the price of one. First, this German exporter gets a competitive advantage, good until the middle of 2006 in my opinion, as a weak euro and a stronger dollar price its products more competitively for U.S. and other dollar-denominated customers. Second, as the dollar's strength and the euro's weakness reverse in 2006, U.S. based investors will pick up gains from the European currency's appreciation. And, third, the company is in the midst of a turnaround that should result in a series of quarters in 2006 dominated by special charges. But that should still drive the stock upwards as investors start to anticipate improved performance in 2007. As of Dec. 21, I'm raising my target price to $87 as of March 2006 from the prior target of $83 by October 2006.

Editor's Note: A new Jubaks Journal is posted every Tuesday, Wednesday and Friday. Please note that Jubak's Picks recommendations are for a 12-to-18 month time horizon. See Jubak's CNBC Picks for shorter six month recommendations. For suggestions to help navigate the treacherous interest-rate environment see Jim's new portfolio Dividend stocks for income investors. For picks with a truly long-term perspective see Jubak's 50 best stocks in the world or Future Fantastic 50 Portfolio.

E-mail Jim Jubak at jjmail@microsoft.com.

At the time of publication, Jim Jubak owned or controlled shares of the following equities mentioned in this column: Chicago Bridge & Iron, EMC, Ensco International, General Cable, Nabors Industries, and Noble He does not own short positions in any stock mentioned in this column.

 

MSN Money's editorial goal is to provide a forum for personal finance and investment ideas. Our articles, columns, message board posts and other features should not be construed as investment advice, nor does their appearance imply an endorsement by Microsoft of any specific security or trading strategy. An investor's best course of action must be based on individual circumstances.